Use of Obsolete Methods

Last revision (mm/dd/yy): 01/22/2016

Description

The use of deprecated or obsolete functions may indicate neglected code.

As programming languages evolve, functions occasionally become obsolete due to:

• Advances in the language
• Improved understanding of how operations should be performed effectively and securely
• Changes in the conventions that govern certain operations
• Functions that are removed are usually replaced by newer counterparts that perform the same task in some different and hopefully improved way.

Refer to the documentation for this function in order to determine why it is deprecated or obsolete and to learn about alternative ways to achieve the same functionality. The remainder of this text discusses general problems that stem from the use of deprecated or obsolete functions.

Risk Factors

• Talk about the factors that make this vulnerability likely or unlikely to actually happen
• Discuss the technical impact of a successful exploit of this vulnerability
• Consider the likely [business impacts] of a successful attack

Examples

The following code uses the deprecated function getpw() to verify that a plaintext password matches a user's encrypted password. If the password is valid, the function sets result to 1; otherwise it is set to 0.

	...
	getpw(uid, pwdline); 	
	for (i=0; i<3; i++){
		cryptpw=strtok(pwdline, ":");
		pwdline=0;
	}
	result = strcmp(crypt(plainpw,cryptpw), cryptpw) == 0;
	...

Although the code often behaves correctly, using the getpw() function can be problematic from a security standpoint, because it can overflow the buffer passed to its second parameter. Because of this vulnerability, getpw() has been supplanted by getpwuid(), which performs the same lookup as getpw() but returns a pointer to a statically-allocated structure to mitigate the risk.

Not all functions are deprecated or replaced because they pose a security risk. However, the presence of an obsolete function often indicates that the surrounding code has been neglected and may be in a state of disrepair. Software security has not been a priority, or even a consideration, for very long. If the program uses deprecated or obsolete functions, it raises the probability that there are security problems lurking nearby.