Talk:REST Security Cheat Sheet

Stateless controversy

Each of these REST calls is stateless and the endpoint should check whether the caller is authorized to perform the requested operation.

TODO's from the latest working group (11/2017)

• describe the scope of the cheat sheet more clearly
  • server to server calls is a special case
• coarse- vs fine-grained authZ
• token usage scenario's
  • short lived
  • bearer
• limitations and mitigations of bearer tokens
• secrets mgmt
  • JWK
  • key management
• a client can obtain security tokens by doing an OAuth or OIDC dance with an authZ server

Avoiding DOR

Will
My point with the Check Authorization for User-Specific Entities section is to avoid Direct Object Reference. There are really two underlying potential pitfalls here:

• Giving access to objects simply by the key value in the URL rather than checking proper authorization for that entity. (i.e., this user doesn't have access to object 1235, but we allow the method simply because 1235 was in the URL rather than checking to see if this user is allowed to modify/view it)
• Giving away sensitive information simply by including the object ID in the URL. Users tend to copy/paste URL's and they get cached in many different places and included in the history (even if the response gives the right Expires, Cache-control, and Pragma headers), so the URL shouldn't directly include anything sensitive like account number. http://some.service/account/128420482 should be a no-no.

Type Validation

Will
I would love to add a section on validating incoming entity definitions via XML or JSON. In XML, you have to deal first with entity expansion (death by a million laughs) because entities are expanded before the XML itself is validated, then need to validate against a DTD, XML-Schema, etc.

I'm just now finding out that there is a loose definition of a JSON validation scheme [1], but I'm not sure if any of the popular server-side JSON frameworks support this built-in, or what the maturity is of any of the implementations at [2]. Anybody have any knowledge on this?
Michael
I was researching between the most popular JavaScript frameworks in order to find a JSON schema validation but it seems that this topic is still immature. But apart from XML and JSON, REST approaches uses syndication feed formats including Atom and RSS.The W3C has a tool for validating those syndication formats.[3]

Payload Attacks

Michael
On top of REST based services,there is a protocol called OData(The Open Data Protocol), OData follows the architectural style of the Web, and allows the HTTP Content negotiation using standard media formats, including XML, JSON, Atom, RSS. Serving data in this formats also increment the risk of payloads attacks. Do you think we should include payloads attacks in this section?

Authentication in Header

Chris H
I've seen quite a few examples of REST services available over HTTPS where the authentication mechanism (API key or the Username and Password) are added to the Headers of a GET rather than send via cookie or POST, this is TLS encrypted and doesn't suffer the exposure problems of having this information in the URI. I wondered if anyone had an opinion on this method, good or bad, how could it be exploited? Could you add something about it to this cheat sheet stating if it is acceptable practice.