Difference between revisions of "OWASP Testing Guide v2 Review Panel"

Revision as of 17:16, 14 November 2006

[Table of Contents]

Update: 13th November, 11.00 (GMT+1)

**********************
Reviewing planning
**********************

The reviewers are: Mark Roxberry, Alberto Revelli, Daniel Cuthbert, Matteo G.P. Flora, Matteo Meucci, Eoin Keary, Stefano Di Paola, James Kist, Vicente Aguilera, Mauro Bregolin, Syed Mohamed A

We can begin the 1st reviewing phase by review all 63 articles (nearly 13 articles per person). The deadline is 15th November at 20.00 (GMT+1) because we have 15th November as 1st deadline for the Autumn of Code Project.

*********************************************
We are waiting for the following articles
*********************************************

4.2.2 Spidering and googling (0%, Tom Brennan, Tom Ryan)
4.2.4.2 DB Listener Testing (0%, Alexander Kornbrust)
4.5.5 HTTP Exploit (0%, Arian J.Evans)
4.6.2.2 Oracle testing (0%,Alexander Kornbrust)
4.6.4 ORM Injection (0%, Mark Roxberry)
5. Writing Reports: value the real risk
5.1 How to value the real risk (50%, Daniel Cuthbert, Matteo Meucci, Sebastien Deleersnyder, Marco Morana)
5.2 How to write the report of the testing (0%, Daniel Cuthbert, Tom Brennan, Tom Ryan)

*********************************************************
Here is the complete list of articles to be reviewed:
********************************************************* _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• Introduction -->...

1 of 1 article to be reviewed -> reviewed by Eoin Keary

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• The OWASP Testing Framework -->...

1 of 1 article to be reviewed

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.1 Introduction and objectives -->.EK

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.2 Information Gathering (Reviewed by EK) --> Keary

9 of 10 articles to be reviewed ->

• Application Discovery:
  • Reviewed + updated(EK) (Maybe we should include HTTP methods for application descovery, such as HTTP HEAD command?)
    
• Analysis of error codes:
  • Reviewed + updated(EK)
    
• Infrastructure configuration management testing AoC:
  • Reviewed by EK. Not in typical guide structure
    
• SSL/TLS Testing AoC:
  • Reviewed + updated(EK)
    
• DB Listener Testing:
  • Incomplete
    
• Application configuration management testing:
  • Reviewed by EK. Not typical guide structure
  • This is generally a "white box" section. There are no examples of testing the configuration from a remote perspective. If this was the aim of the document, thats fine. - Need feedback on this one!!
  • Sample/known files and directories: might be good to refer to http://www.owasp.org/index.php/Old_file_testing_AoC ??
  • Logging: Timestamp is also important
• File extensions handling
  
  • contains the text: "...To review and expand..." - Is this complete??
  • Need a second opinion on this one!! :)
• Old file testing: Reviewed by EK

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.3 Business logic testing -->...

1 of 1 article to be reviewed

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.4 Authentication Testing --> Roxberry

5 of 5 articles to be reviewed

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.5 Session Management Testing --> Syed Mohamed A

5 of 6 articles to be reviewed

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.6 Data Validation Testing --> Meucci

18 of 21 articles to be reviewed

• • 4.6 Data Validation Testing : Reviewed by EK
  • 4.6.1 - Cross site scripting: Reviewed by EK (Reformatted it slightly with wiki tags)
  • 4.6.1.1 HTTP Methods and XST Reviewed by MM
  • 4.6.2 SQL Injection (90%) Reviewed by MM. Eoin can you review Eng, please?
  • 4.6.2.1 Stored procedure injection (40%) TD
  • 4.6.2.2 Oracle testing (0%) TD
  • 4.6.2.3 MySQL testing (100%) Reviewed by MM
  • 4.6.2.4 SQL Server testing (95%)
  • 4.6.3 LDAP Injection (90%)
  • 4.6.4 ORM Injection (0%)
  • 4.6.5 XML Injection (80%)
  • 4.6.6 SSI Injection (95%)
  • 4.6.7 XPath Injection (80%)
  • 4.6.8 IMAP/SMTP Injection (95%)
  • 4.6.9 Code Injection (70%)
  • 4.6.10 OS Commanding (70%)
  • 4.6.11 Buffer overflow Testing (100%)
  • 4.6.11.1 Heap overflow (100%)
  • 4.6.11.2 Stack overflow (100%)
  • 4.6.11.3 Format string (100%)
  • 4.6.12 Incubated vulnerability testing (95%)

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.7 Denial of Service Testing --> being reviewed by Revelli

8 of 8 articles to be reviewed

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.8 Web Services Testing -->...

6 of 6 articles to be reviewed (No Keary)

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 4.9 AJAX Testing --> Roxberry

6 of 6 articles to be reviewed (No Di Paola)

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• 5. Writing Reports: value the real risk

We have to write about it. I consider it not yet finished. O of 3 articles to be reviewed.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• Appendix A: Testing Tools -->...

1 article of 1: need to update it searching all the guide for paragraps: tools

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• Appendix B: Suggested Reading -->...

1 article of 1: need to update it searching all the guide for paragraps: tools

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

• Appendix C: Fuzz Vectors -->...

1 article of 1: Need to be updated

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ *************************
Reviewers Rules
*************************

1) Check the english language
2) Check the template: the articles on chapter 4 should have the following:

• Template (http://www.owasp.org/index.php/Template_Paragraph_Testing_AoC)

In some articles we don't need to talk about Gray Box Testing or other, so we can eliminate it.

3) Check the reference style. (I'd like to have all the referenced URLs visible because I have to produce also a pdf document of the Guide). I agree with Stefano, we have to use a reference like that:

== References ==

'''Whitepapers'''<br>

* [1] Author1, Author2: "Title" - http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2254.txt<br>

* [2]...<br>

'''Tools'''<br>

* Francois Larouche: "Multiple DBMS Sql Injection tool" - http://www.sqlpowerinjector.com/index.htm <br>

4) Check the reference with the other articles of the guide or with the other OWASP Project.

5) Other?