Difference between revisions of "OWASP Internet of Things Top Ten Project"

• Ensure that any web interface in the product disallows weak passwords
• Ensure that any web interface in the product has an account lockout mechanism
• Ensure that any web interface in the product has been tested for XSS, SQLi and CSRF vulnerabilities
• Ensure that any web interface has the ability to use HTTPS to protect transmitted information
• Include web application firewalls to protect any web interfaces
• Ensure that any web interface allows the owner to change the default username and password

• Ensure that any access requiring authentication requires strong passwords
• Ensure that user roles can be properly segregated in multi-user environments
• Implement two-factor authentication where possible
• Ensure password recovery mechanisms are secure
• Ensure that users have the option to require strong passwords
• Ensure that users have the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Ensure that users have the option to change the default username and password

• Ensure all devices operate with a minimal number of network ports active
• Ensure all devices do not make network ports and/or services available to the internet via UPnP for example
• Review all required network services for vulnerabilities such as buffer overflows or denial of service

• Ensure all communication between system components is encrypted as well as encrypting traffic between the system or device and the internet
• Use recommended and accepted encryption practices and avoid proprietary protocols
• Ensure SSL/TLS implementations are up to date and properly configured
• Consider making a firewall option available for the product

• Ensure only the minimal amount of personal information is collected from consumers
• Ensure all collected personal data is properly protected using encryption at rest and in transit
• Ensure only authorized individuals have access to collected personal information
• Ensure only less sensitive data is collected
• Ensuring data is de-identified or anonymized
• Ensuring a data retention policy is in place
• Ensuring end-users are given a choice for data collected beyond what is needed for proper operation of the device

• Ensure all cloud interfaces are reviewed for security vulnerabilities (e.g. API interfaces and cloud-based web interfaces)
• Ensure that any cloud-based web interface disallows weak passwords
• Ensure that any cloud-based web interface has an account lockout mechanism
• Implement two-factor authentication for cloud-based web interfaces
• Ensure that all cloud interfaces use transport encryption
• Ensure that any cloud-based web interface has been tested for XSS, SQLi and CSRF vulnerabilities
• Ensure that users have the option to require strong passwords
• Ensure that users have the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Ensure that users have the option to change the default username and password

• Ensure that any mobile application disallows weak passwords
• Ensure that any mobile application has an account lockout mechanism
• Implement two-factor authentication for mobile applications (e.g Apple's Touch ID)
• Ensure that any mobile application uses transport encryption
• Ensure that users have the option to require strong passwords
• Ensure that users have the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Ensure that users have the option to change the default username and password

• Ensure password security options are made available (e.g. Enabling 20 character passwords or enabling two-factor authentication)
• Ensure encryption options are made available (e.g. Enabling AES-256 where AES-128 is the default setting)
• Ensure secure logging is available for security events
• Ensure alerts and notifications are available to the user for security events

• Ensure all system devices have update capability and can be updated quickly when vulnerabilities are discovered
• Ensure update files are encrypted and that the files are also transmitted using encryption
• Ensure that update files are signed and then validated by the device before installing
• Ensure update servers are secure
• Ensure the product has the ability to implement scheduled updates

• Ensure the device is produced with a minimal number of physical external ports (e.g. USB ports)
• Ensure the firmware of Operating System can not be accessed via unintended methods such as through an unnecessary USB port
• Ensure the product is tamper resistant
• Ensure the product has the ability to limit administrative capabilities in some fashion, possibly by only connecting locally for admin functions
• Ensure the product has the ability to disable external ports such as USB

• Ensure that any web interface coding is written to prevent the use of weak passwords
• Ensure that any web interface coding is written to include an account lockout mechanism
• Ensure that any web interface coding has been tested for XSS, SQLi and CSRF vulnerabilities
• Ensure that any web interface has the ability to use HTTPS to protect transmitted information
• Ensure that any web interface coding is written to allow the owner to change the username and password
• Consider the use of web application firewalls to protect any web interfaces

When building a web interface consider implementing lessons learned from web application security. Employ a framework that utilizes security controls to ensure that vulnerabilities are mitigated in code. Be sure to plan for eventual upgrades or security fixes to the framework as well. If you use optional plugins to the framework be sure to review them for security.

Deploy and protect the web interface in the same way you would any web application. Utilize encrypted transport protocols if possible, being sure to validate certificates. Limit access in whatever ways possible. Assume users will not change configuration so deploy in a secure manner with strong credentials already in place.

• Ensure that applications are written to require strong passwords where authentication is needed
• Ensure the application takes into account multi-user environments and includes functionality for role separation
• Implement two-factor authentication where possible
• Ensure password recovery mechanisms are written to function in a secure manner
• Ensure that applications are written to include the option to require strong passwords
• Ensure that applications are written to include the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Ensure that applications are written to include the option to change the default username and password

Refer to the OWASP Authentication Cheat Sheet

• Ensure applications that use network services don't respond poorly to buffer overflow, fuzzing or denial of service attacks
• Ensure applications test ports are taken out of service before going to production

Try to utilize tested, proven, networking stacks and interfaces that handle exceptions gracefully. Be sure that any test or maintenance interfaces are disabled or properly protected. Avoid exposing unauthenticated protocols (such as TFTP) or unencrypted channels (such as telnet) if possible. Consider the attack surface that device network services present. Turn off unnecessary services and deploy measures to protect required services, detect malicious activity, and react to an attack with measures such as lock-outs or temporary firewall rules.

• Ensure all applications are written to make use of encrypted communication between devices and between devices and the internet
• Use recommended and accepted encryption practices and avoid proprietary protocols
• Consider making a firewall option available for the application

Utilize encrypted protocols wherever possible to protect all data in transit. Where protocol encryption is not possible consider encrypting data before transfer.

• Ensure only the minimal amount of personal information is collected from consumers
• Ensure all collected personal data is properly protected using encryption at rest and in transit
• Ensuring data is de-identified or anonymized
• Ensuring end-users are given a choice for data collected beyond what is needed for proper operation of the device

Data can present unintended privacy concerns when aggregated. As a rule collect the minimal amount of data possible. Consult with data scientists, legal and compliance teams to determine risk of data collection and storage. Consider implications of consent and the fact that IoT devices may not present an interface for collecting consent and may passively collect data about people other than owners and operators. IoT may collect information about individuals who cannot provide consent (such as minors) and data collection should be modified accordingly.

• Ensure all cloud interfaces are reviewed for security vulnerabilities (e.g. API interfaces and cloud-based web interfaces)
• Ensure that any cloud-based web interface coding is written to disallows weak passwords
• Ensure that any cloud-based web interface coding is written to include an account lockout mechanism
• Implement two-factor authentication for cloud-based web interfaces
• Ensure that any cloud interface coding has been tested for XSS, SQLi and CSRF vulnerabilities
• Ensure that all cloud interfaces use transport encryption
• Ensure that cloud interfaces are written to include the option to require strong passwords
• Ensure that cloud interfaces are written to include the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Ensure that cloud interfaces are written to include the option to change the default username and password

Cloud security presents unique security considerations, as well as countermeasures. Be sure to consult your cloud provider about options for security mechanisms. Consult the OWASP Cloud Top 10 Security Risks documents.

• Ensure that any mobile application coding is written to disallows weak passwords
• Ensure that any mobile application coding is written to include an account lockout mechanism
• Implement two-factor authentication for mobile applications (e.g Apple's Touch ID)
• Ensure that any mobile application uses transport encryption
• Ensure that mobile interfaces are written to include the option to require strong passwords
• Ensure that mobile interfaces are written to include the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Ensure that mobile interfaces are written to include the option to change the default username and password
• Ensure that mobile interfaces only collect the minimum amount of personal information needed

Mobile interfaces to IoT ecosystems require targeted security. Consult the OWASP Mobile Project for further guidance.

• Ensure applications are written to include password security options (e.g. Enabling 20 character passwords or enabling two-factor authentication)
• Ensure applications are written to include encryption options (e.g. Enabling AES-256 where AES-128 is the default setting)
• Ensure all applications are written to produce logs for security events
• Ensure all applications are written to produce alerts and notifications to the user for security events

Security can be a value proposition. Design should take into consideration a sliding scale of security requirements. Architect projects with secure defaults and allow consumers to select options to be enabled or disabled. IoT design should be forward compatible with respect to security - as cipher suites increase and new security technologies become widely available IoT design should be able to adopt these new technologies.

Remember the security lifecycle of protect, detect, and react. Design systems to allow for the detection of malicious activity as well as self defending capabilities and a reaction plan should a compromise be detected. Design all stages of the lifecycle to be evolutionary so improvements can be added to a system or device future releases, updates, or patches.

• Ensure all applications are written to include update capability and can be updated quickly when vulnerabilities are discovered
• Ensure all applications are written to process encrypted update files and that the files are transmitted using encryption
• Ensure all applications are written to process signed files and then validate that file before installation

Many IoT deployments are either brownfield (i.e. applied over existing infrastructure) and/or have an extremely long deployment cycle. To maintain the security of devices over time it is critical to plan for patches and updates.

Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability (CIA) are primary concerns when providing binaries and updates to edge devices. Encrypt updates before distribution, providing decryption keys along with download instructions to authorized devices. Updates should have cryptographic signatures using public key cryptography that can be verified by devices. A cryptographic signature allows for distribution of updates over untrusted channels, such as Content Delivery Network (CDN), peer-to-peer, or machine to machine (M2M).

Devices should always validate cryptographic certificates and discard updates that are not properly delivered or signed. If unencrypted updates are utilized be sure that a cryptographic hash of the update is provided over an encrypted channel so the device can detect tampering.

Provide a mechanism for issuing, updating and revoking cryptographic keys as well. Key management and lifecycle should be taken into consideration prior to deployment. This includes the SSL trust store, or root trust, on a device, which may have to be modified over the lifespan of the device.

• Ensure applications are written to utilize a minimal number of physical external ports (e.g. USB ports) on the device
• Ensure all applications can not be accessed via unintended methods such as through an unnecessary USB port
• Ensure all applications are written to allow for disabling of unused physical ports such as USB
• Consider writing applications to limit administrative capabilities to a local interface only

Plan on having IoT edge devices fall into malicious hands. Utilize whatever physical security protections are available. Disable any testing or debugging interfaces, utilize Hardware Security Modules (HSM's), cryptographic co-processors, and Trusted Platform Modules (TPM's) wherever possible.

Consider the implications of a compromised device. Do not share credentials, application or cryptographic keys across multiple devices to limit the scope of damage due to a physical compromise.

Plan for the transfer of ownership of devices and ensure that data is not transferable along with the ownership.

• Assess any web interface to determine if weak passwords are allowed
• Assess the account lockout mechanism
• Assess the web interface for XSS, SQLi and CSRF vulnerabilities and other web application vulnerabilities
• Assess the use of HTTPS to protect transmitted information
• Assess the ability to change the username and password
• Determine if web application firewalls are used to protect web interfaces

• Assess the solution for the use of strong passwords where authentication is needed
• Assess the solution for multi-user environments and ensure it includes functionality for role separation
• Assess the solution for Implementation two-factor authentication where possible
• Assess password recovery mechanisms
• Assess the solution for the option to require strong passwords
• Assess the solution for the option to force password expiration after a specific period
• Assess the solution for the option to change the default username and password

• Assess the solution to ensure network services don't respond poorly to buffer overflow, fuzzing or denial of service attacks
• Assess the solution to ensure test ports are are not present

• Assess the solution to determine the use of encrypted communication between devices and between devices and the internet
• Assess the solution to determine if accepted encryption practices are used and if proprietary protocols are avoided
• Assess the solution to determine if a firewall option available is available

• Assess the solution to determine the amount of personal information collected
• Assess the solution to determine if collected personal data is properly protected using encryption at rest and in transit
• Assess the solution to determine if Ensuring data is de-identified or anonymized
• Assess the solution to ensure end-users are given a choice for data collected beyond what is needed for proper operation of the device

• Assess the cloud interfaces for security vulnerabilities (e.g. API interfaces and cloud-based web interfaces)
• Assess the cloud-based web interface to ensure it disallows weak passwords
• Assess the cloud-based web interface to ensure it includes an account lockout mechanism
• Assess the cloud-based web interface to determine if two-factor authentication is used
• Assess any cloud interfaces for XSS, SQLi and CSRF vulnerabilities and other vulnerabilities
• Assess all cloud interfaces to ensure transport encryption is used
• Assess the cloud interfaces to determine if the option to require strong passwords is available
• Assess the cloud interfaces to determine if the option to force password expiration after a specific period is available
• Assess the cloud interfaces to determine if the option to change the default username and password is available

• Assess the mobile interface to ensure it disallows weak passwords
• Assess the mobile interface to ensure it includes an account lockout mechanism
• Assess the mobile interface to determine if it Implements two-factor authentication (e.g Apple's Touch ID)
• Assess the mobile interface to determine if it uses transport encryption
• Assess the mobile interface to determine if the option to require strong passwords is available
• Assess the mobile interface to determine if the option to force password expiration after a specific period is available
• Assess the mobile interface to determine if the option to change the default username and password is available
• Assess the mobile interface to determine the amount of personal information collected

• Assess the solution to determine if password security options (e.g. Enabling 20 character passwords or enabling two-factor authentication) are available
• Assess the solution to determine if encryption options (e.g. Enabling AES-256 where AES-128 is the default setting) are available
• Assess the solution to determine if logging for security events is available
• Assess the solution to determine if alerts and notifications to the user for security events are available

• Assess the device to ensure it includes update capability and can be updated quickly when vulnerabilities are discovered
• Assess the device to ensure it uses encrypted update files and that the files are transmitted using encryption
• Assess the device to ensure is uses signed files and then validates that file before installation

• Assess the device to ensure it utilizes a minimal number of physical external ports (e.g. USB ports) on the device
• Assess the device to determine if it can be accessed via unintended methods such as through an unnecessary USB port
• Assess the device to determine if it allows for disabling of unused physical ports such as USB
• Assess the device to determine if it includes the ability to limit administrative capabilities to a local interface only

• If your system has the option to use HTTPS, ensure it is enabled
• If your system has a two factor authentication option, ensure that it is enabled
• If your system has web application firewall option, ensure that it is enabled
• If your system has a local or cloud-based web application, ensure that you change the default password to a strong one and if possible change the default username as well
• If the system has account lockout functionality, ensure that it is enabled
• Consider employing network segmentation technologies such as firewalls to isolate IoT systems from critical IT systems

• If your system has a local or cloud-based web application, ensure that you change the default password to a strong one and if possible change the default username as well
• If the system has account lockout functionality, ensure that it is enabled
• If the system has the option to require strong passwords, ensure that is enabled
• If the system has the option to require new passwords after 90 days for example, ensure that is enabled
• If your system has a two factor authentication option, ensure that it is enabled
• If your system has the option to set user privileges, consider setting user privileges to the minimal needed for operation
• Consider employing network segmentation technologies such as firewalls to isolate IoT systems from critical IT systems

• If your system has a firewall option available, enable it and ensure that it can only be accessed from your client systems
• Consider employing network segmentation technologies such as firewalls to isolate IoT systems from critical IT systems

• If your system has the option to use HTTPS, ensure it is enabled

• Do not enter sensitive information into the system that is not absolutely required, e.g. address, DOB, CC, etc.
• Deny data collection if it appears to be beyond what is needed for proper operation of the device (If provided the choice)

• If your system has the option to use HTTPS, ensure it is enabled
• If your system has a two factor authentication option, ensure that it is enabled
• If your system has web application firewall option, ensure that it is enabled
• If your system has a local or cloud-based web application, ensure that you change the default password to a strong one and if possible change the default username as well
• If the system has account lockout functionality, ensure that it is enabled
• If the system has the option to require strong passwords, ensure that is enabled
• If the system has the option to require new passwords after 90 days for example, ensure that is enabled

• If the mobile application has the option to require a PIN or password, consider using it for extra security (on client and server)
• If the mobile application has the option to use two factory authentication such as Apple's Touch ID, ensure it is enabled
• If the system has account lockout functionality, ensure that it is enabled
• If the system has the option to require strong passwords, ensure that is enabled
• If the system has the option to require new passwords after 90 days for example, ensure that is enabled
• Do not enter sensitive information into the mobile application that is not absolutely required, e.g. address, DOB, CC, etc.

• If your system has the option, enable any logging functionality for security-related events
• If your system has the option, enable any alert and notification functionality for security-related events
• If your system has security options for passwords, ensure they are enabled for strong passwords
• If your system has security options for encryption, ensure they are set for an accepted standard such as AES-256

• If your system has the option to verify updates, ensure it is enabled
• If your system has the option to download updates securely, ensure it is enabled
• If your system has the ability to schedule updates on a regular cadence, consider enabling it

• If your system has the ability to limit administrative capabilities possible by connecting locally, consider enabling that feature
• Disable any unused physical ports through the administrative interface